Re: film sound and Hi-MD (minidisk) format conundrum

From: Josephine Shokrian (email suppressed)
Date: Mon Dec 10 2007 - 14:25:26 PST

well that's the problem with that format

Hi-MD when it first came out was a great idea

you could import it straight into the computer

but since minidisc format is not very popular they

tend to discontinue the formats very quickly. Last

time I tried to buy a HI-MD disc I couldn't find one.

alas their is no real way to get around it. The Hi-MD

will only work on that type of player. you might be

able to find one online and then return it. I got mine

from a place on the net called but I'm

sure amazon and some other sights would have it.

good luck

Sent via BlackBerry from T-Mobile

-----Original Message-----
From: amanda christie <email suppressed>

Date: Mon, 10 Dec 2007 10:43:25
To:email suppressed
Subject: film sound and Hi-MD (minidisk) format conundrum

Hello all,

i have bit of a sound dillema... wondering if anyone
can offer some advice.

I am working on a film right now, but the audio
recordings that I want to use have already been made
using a Hi-MD format recorder. Unfortunately, I
cannot find the proper technology to play back
Hi-mini-disk format or to import it into my
computer... so I have this lovely little disk... that
has lovely little sounds on it.... that i can't get

I recorded them in Canada onto mini-disk using a
Hi-mini-disk recorder. At the time... I thought that
all mini-disk recorders were the same. Alas, I was

it turns out, that there are "regular-mini-disk",
"Net-mini-disk" and "Hi-mini-disk" formats. the disks
are the same for all formats. the only difference is
in the recorder. something recorded on a Hi-MD
recorder can only be played back on a Hi-MD player
(apparently)... yet, a Hi-MD player can play back any
format.... Net-MD can play back regular and Net
formats, but not Hi formats... and regular MD can only
play back regular formats....

make sense?

When in Vancouver, I ran into this dillema... (with
another disk in the same series)... I went to the Sony
store, and they had only one Hi-MD player at it was
$500 and non-returnable (i was thinking of buying,
importing sound, then returning)... so i couldn't
swing that... finally i found someone with a Hi-MD
player, borrowed it, dumped my sound, and gave it
back... so I know that the sounds ARE on the disks...
i just can't get at the ones i want now.

Does anyone have any advice on this?

either where to get a Hi-MD player.... I'm living in
Amsterdam right now... but then going back to the East
Coast of Canada (Halifax/Moncton) next week... and
then I'll be in Rotterdam as of Dec. 30...

Alternately, does anyone know a way around this? some
way to get the Hi MD files off without a Hi-MD player?

any tips or suggestions would be very helpful. I'm
getting to be a bit desperate as I was hoping to
finish my sound design this month. eek!

amanda dawn christie

      Looking for the perfect gift? Give the gift of Flickr!

For info on FrameWorks, contact Pip Chodorov at <email suppressed>.

For info on FrameWorks, contact Pip Chodorov at <email suppressed>.